Leech Lake Tribal College
Menu
On this page

Search strategy and hiring

How to Hire an AI SEO Expert: Complete Guide

Give each finalist the same public page and the same customer question. Ask them to explain what they can verify, what they would change, and how your team would check the change. That exercise tells you how they will work when the data is incomplete and a release needs someone’s approval.

A person marks a printed web page beside an inspection checklist.
A work sample should connect a specific page finding to a repair your team can verify.

Decide what you need the expert to do

An AI SEO expert helps make your public pages easier to discover and understand in traditional search and AI-generated search answers. The work can include checking crawl and index eligibility, fixing conflicting pages, and improving the material search systems can draw on. If the team also uses AI to draft copy, give that work its own review and approval process. Compare those responsibilities when you look at AI SEO services.

Start with an outcome someone on your team cares about. A college program might want prospective students to find the current entry requirements and reach the application page. A service business might want people comparing providers to see its service area and request a quote. Collect the questions people already ask, identify the pages that should answer them, and pick the action you can measure. A starting point for collecting those questions is the SBA’s market research guide.

Choose the team structure that can deliver

Independent specialist
Use a specialist for a defined problem, a second opinion, or a pilot your developers and editors can implement. Verify their availability during review and release.
Agency
Consider an agency when the work needs coordination across technical SEO, writing, and outreach. Interview the named people doing the work and ask who owns quality control.
In-house hire
Hire internally when search work recurs across releases and needs someone embedded with product, engineering, and editorial teams. Identify who covers specialist work during busy periods.

If a developer and editor are already available, the missing role may be someone to diagnose issues, set priorities, and verify the work. Describe that remit when interviewing an SEO strategy consultant.

Shortlist candidates using comparable evidence

Ask peers who have shipped a similar project, look through professional communities, and use portfolios or directories to find candidates with relevant work. Give everyone the same brief. Include the site and audience, the pages or templates in scope, your team’s release process, and what help you need with implementation. Ask what they would need to know before committing to a proposal.

Request a redacted work example with a baseline, a dated change, and the evidence the candidate checked afterward. Ask who did the implementation and what the customer owned. If they show a rise in traffic, ask for the affected URLs, period, and query or page filters. Ask which other releases, campaigns, or seasonal changes could have contributed. The goal is to learn which decisions they can explain and defend.

For a project involving topic gaps, have the candidate describe how they compare the same market and time window and check whether a missing term matches a real audience need. Compatible exports can be compared using a competitor keyword comparison.

Ask the same questions in every interview

  1. What would you check first? Listen for the page, the problem, the available evidence, and what the candidate needs before changing anything.
  2. How would you handle different answers across AI search platforms? Look for a repeatable set of questions and a plan to record platform, date, cited URL, and missing answers.
  3. Tell me about an SEO recommendation you withdrew. Ask what evidence changed their mind and how they communicated the decision.
  4. Who would ship and check the first change? Have them name the owner, what access they need, the acceptance check, and when they would review the result.

Give interviewers the questions and scoring criteria in advance. Have them record their scores independently before discussing candidates. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management outlines this approach in its guide to structured interviews.

Run a paid work sample on one public URL

Send finalists a page and an actual audience question it should answer. For a public certificate program page, that might be what a prospective student needs before applying and where to complete the next step. Set a short time limit, agree on payment and what you can use afterward, and offer the same public material or sanitized exports to everyone. Ask for one prioritized finding, one proposed change, and one check after release. A finding can also justify leaving the page alone.

A brief you can send to each finalist

Use the public URL and audience question we supplied. Identify the issue that matters most for this reader, or explain why the page is already fit for the task. Show where you found your evidence, what change you would make, and who would need to approve it. Describe how you would verify the page after release and which checks need data you haven’t seen. Bring a short written answer that we can discuss together.

Ask candidates to point to the text, URL state, or report behind their recommendation. For a content change, have them write the part they would revise and identify the authoritative source. For a technical change, ask them to show how the problem can be reproduced and who can fix it. Let them mark checks that require property access as pending. Give credit for a concrete plan to resolve that uncertainty.

If the proposed fix is editorial, ask for an outline, evidence sources, internal links, and a named reviewer. Your team can give every candidate the same template or use a content brief builder.

When candidates propose adding structured data, ask them which visible facts the markup describes and how they will test the revision. They can inspect a public page or check a pasted block using a schema markup validator.

Read the rewrite as a prospective visitor. Check whether you can find the condition that applies to you and complete the next step. A readability score calculator can flag dense passages for review. Assess whether the copy uses words the audience recognizes and puts the decision information first using plain language guidance.

Score what the candidate can demonstrate

Score each row from 0 to 2. Give 0 when the response omits the item, 1 for a plausible approach with missing evidence, and 2 when the response meets the standard below. Use the score to structure your discussion. Treat requests for excessive access and unverifiable promises as separate hiring decisions.

Work sample scoring rubric
CriterionEvidence for a score of 2
DiagnosisPoints to the exact URL, observation and evidence needed to confirm the issue.
PrioritizationExplains which reader or business task the change helps and why it comes first.
ImplementationDescribes the change, names the owner and identifies release dependencies.
Search judgmentSeparates an eligibility check, a citation observation and a measured outcome.
VerificationSpecifies a repeatable acceptance check, a baseline and a follow-up date.

During the walkthrough, change one constraint. Ask what they would do if the editor could update copy this week and the developer could change the template next month. A good answer explains what can be delivered now, what should wait, and how to verify that the interim edit serves the reader.

Compare costs and agree on the handoff

Compare quotes on the same deliverable. Ask for separate lines for diagnosis, content revisions, implementation, measurement, and software or data subscriptions. For a defined issue, a fixed-price audit or pilot can make scope easier to compare. Hourly support suits variable advisory work if the proposal includes a cap or review point. A retainer fits an ongoing backlog when it specifies capacity, owners, and the cadence for accepting work.

Ask each bidder to list the URLs or templates included, who drafts and publishes, what your team must provide, and how extra work will be approved. Request a sample audit issue with an affected URL and a check you can perform after release. Write down which editable files, exports, and accounts you keep at the end. Google recommends asking how the specialist measures success and how they share changes in its SEO hiring guidance.

If outreach is in scope, ask to see an example of a proposed guest post before approving a fee. You should be able to tell whom the article serves, who can edit it, how compensation will be disclosed, and how referral visits will be measured. For a campaign serving U.S. readers, start with the audience fit of the USA guest posting sites being considered. Verify the publisher’s terms separately from the shortlist.

Treat paid editorial-format advertising as a distinct purchase. Ask the supplier to explain how readers will recognize the ad using the FTC’s native advertising guidance. Reject proposals that price paid ranking credit as a deliverable. Google describes buying links for ranking purposes as link spam.

Keep control of accounts and release decisions

Begin evaluation with public pages, redacted reports, or read-only access to the specific property needed. Use a named account. Have your team retain ownership of analytics, Search Console, the domain, and the CMS. Agree on who approves crawler changes, who can publish, and how access will be removed after the engagement. Keep customer or student records out of work samples and prompt logs.

Ask the candidate to describe Google AI search eligibility for the site before suggesting a fix. For Google’s generative search features, a page must be indexed and eligible for a Search snippet, and the site must be included in those features through Search Console. Check the site setting and the affected URL separately, following Google’s guidance for generative AI features.

Make crawler decisions by provider and purpose. For example, OpenAI has separate controls for OAI-SearchBot for search and GPTBot for potential training use. Ask for the specific rule and its reason, check any relevant firewall settings, and have the owner approve the intended policy after reviewing OpenAI’s crawler documentation.

Agree on what the first month will show

Agree on three milestones your team can review even when search reporting lags.

  1. Accept the baseline. Export data for the pages in scope. Record the reporting dates and filters, check that the target action is tracked, and log relevant releases and campaigns.
  2. Approve a small change set. Agree on a named approver, an implementation owner, and what to check on the changed URLs. Record any dependency that could delay the release.
  3. Review the change record. If implementation is in scope, have the specialist show the live pages and demonstrate the checks. If a dependency delays the change, review the finding and handoff while the release is pending.
Three clipped records on a workbench depict a baseline, change and follow-up check.
Keep the baseline, release record, and follow-up check together for each priority page.

Keep four kinds of evidence separate

Work shipped
Record the changed URL, approved edit, release date and acceptance check. Check the live page before marking the work complete.
Organic search
Compare impressions and clicks for the same page set, date range length, country and device filters. Track query positions with documented sampling if you use a keyword position tracker.
AI search visibility
Track Google feature impressions separately from Microsoft citations. Label the scope of each source and keep a dated set of audience questions for platform checks.
Business outcome
Measure the target action, such as qualified enquiries or application starts. Record the analytics source, attribution rules and known gaps before drawing a conclusion.

Google’s dedicated Search Console report breaks out impressions in generative features such as AI Overviews and AI Mode. Those observations also contribute to overall Search performance. Use the Generative AI performance reports.

Microsoft counts citations across its supported AI surfaces. Put that count in a separate column from clicks and conversions in your own reporting. You can check the cited URLs and counts in Bing Webmaster Tools’ AI Performance report.

For a manual prompt panel, keep the prompt, platform, date, market and observed sources. Record brand mentions and linked citations separately. Log failed checks and the number of completed observations so that any rates can be compared. Use public answers or sanitized exports when compiling them in an AI brand visibility checker.

Review process and outcomes on separate schedules. The first review should tell you whether the specialist delivered the agreed work and whether your team can reproduce their checks. Later reviews can compare visibility and conversions with a baseline and flag other changes that may affect the comparison. A new campaign or a seasonal shift in demand can be a confounding factor.

Questions to settle before you sign

Can an expert guarantee a citation or a top ranking?

Search systems decide which pages they show and which sources appear in each answer. Pay for work the expert can control and your team can verify. Have the supplier put any performance forecast alongside the data, assumptions, and evaluation period behind it.

Should you hire an expert for advice or implementation?

Look at your release queue and who can edit the site. A consulting engagement can work when your developers and editors have capacity and a named owner. If the queue is already full, include implementation hours, review rights, and live checks in the proposal you compare.

When is it worth extending a pilot?

Extend when the supplier delivers usable work, documents uncertainty, and can explain what they learned from the checks. Pick the next set of pages based on what the pilot reveals and the business action you need. If a result is too early to interpret, agree on what evidence you will review and when.